What Is The Difference Between Conventional Nested And Real Time Pcr Assays

Polymerase Chain Reaction (PCR) is a cornerstone technique in molecular biology that enables the amplification of specific DNA sequences from minute quantities. This method has revolutionized genetic analysis, enabling rapid diagnostics and research advancements. By manipulating conditions and ingredients, scientists can target a tiny DNA sample and amplify it billions of times for detailed study.

Conventional nested PCR and real-time PCR are two variations of this essential technique, each with unique features and applications. Conventional nested PCR is known for its high specificity, achieved by using two sets of primers in two successive reactions. In contrast, real-time PCR allows the quantification of DNA in real time, providing a faster and quantitative analysis without the need for further processing.

While both methods serve the purpose of amplifying DNA, they differ significantly in their approach and utility. Conventional nested PCR is preferred for its sensitivity in detecting low-abundance targets, whereas real-time PCR offers the advantage of simultaneous amplification and quantification, making it ideal for diagnostic and quantitative studies.

PCR Basics

Definition and Mechanism

Polymerase Chain Reaction (PCR) is a technique used to amplify a segment of DNA into millions or even billions of copies. This method is crucial in research, medical diagnostics, forensics, and more. The principle behind PCR is relatively straightforward—it mimics the natural DNA replication process in a controlled laboratory setting.

Components of a PCR Reaction

A typical PCR setup involves several key components:

  • DNA Template: This is the DNA sequence that needs to be copied.
  • Primers: Short DNA fragments that initiate the DNA replication.
  • DNA Polymerase: An enzyme that assembles the nucleotides to form new strands of DNA.
  • Nucleotides (dNTPs): Building blocks that are added to the growing DNA strand.
ALSO READ:  Difference Between Tmj And Tmd

Role in Amplifying DNA

PCR amplifies DNA by cycling through three main temperature steps:

  1. Denaturation: The double-stranded DNA melts and opens into two pieces of single-stranded DNA at high temperature.
  2. Annealing: Temperature is lowered to enable the DNA primers to attach to the DNA template.
  3. Extension: DNA polymerase adds nucleotides to form new strands of DNA, duplicating the original DNA.

This cycle is repeated 30-40 times to produce a significant amount of DNA from a very small sample.

Conventional Nested PCR

Overview and Process Description

Conventional nested PCR is a variation of PCR designed to increase specificity and sensitivity. This method uses two pairs of primers in two successive rounds of PCR to amplify a target DNA sequence. The second set of primers binds within the product of the first PCR, thereby reducing non-specific binding and amplifying the target sequence more selectively.

Specificity and Sensitivity

Nested PCR is highly specific due to the use of two sets of primers, drastically reducing the background noise seen with non-specific amplification. Its sensitivity makes it an excellent choice for detecting low-abundance targets in complex DNA mixtures.

Common Applications

Nested PCR is often used in:

  • Pathogen Detection: Identifying bacterial and viral infections.
  • Genetic Disorders: Detecting mutations associated with diseases.
  • Environmental Monitoring: Assessing biodiversity from environmental samples.

Real Time PCR

Definition and Operational Mechanism

Real-time PCR, also known as quantitative PCR (qPCR), monitors the amplification of a targeted DNA molecule during the PCR, i.e., in real time. It combines the amplification and detection steps into one homogeneous phase, which helps in quantifying the DNA. This is achieved using fluorescent markers that emit a signal proportional to the amount of DNA amplified during the PCR cycles.

Advantages Over Other PCR Techniques

Real-time PCR offers several advantages:

  • Speed: Significantly faster as it combines amplification and detection into a single step.
  • Quantification: Allows precise quantification of the initial amount of DNA.
  • Lower Contamination Risk: Does not require post-PCR handling, reducing the risk of sample contamination.

Applications in Real-Time Analysis

This method is widely used in:

  • Clinical Diagnostics: Detecting and quantifying viral loads in patient samples.
  • Genetic Expression: Measuring changes in gene expression levels.
  • Food Safety: Identifying and quantifying genetically modified organisms in food products.
ALSO READ:  What Is The Difference Between Merthiolate And Mercurochrome

Key Differences

Amplification Monitoring

  • Conventional Nested PCR: Does not provide real-time monitoring; results are analyzed after the process.
  • Real Time PCR: Monitors the amplification of DNA during the PCR process, providing immediate insights into the reaction dynamics.

Speed and Efficiency

Real-time PCR is generally quicker than nested PCR due to the integration of amplification and detection phases, offering more rapid results which are crucial in clinical settings.

Application Scope

While nested PCR is suited for applications requiring high sensitivity and specificity, real-time PCR is preferred in scenarios where rapid, quantitative results are needed.

Cost Implications

Real-time PCR requires more expensive equipment and reagents, particularly because of the fluorescent markers used in quantification. Despite higher initial costs, the efficiency and speed can justify the investment in many scenarios.

Technical Considerations

Primer Design and Optimization

Successful PCR experiments hinge on effective primer design. Primers need to specifically bind to the target DNA sequence without binding to non-target sequences. Several factors are critical for primer design:

  • Specificity: Primers should exclusively bind to the target sequence.
  • Melting Temperature (Tm): Both primers should have a similar Tm to ensure they bind efficiently during the annealing phase.
  • Length: Typically, primers are 18-25 bases long to ensure specific binding.
  • GC Content: Aim for 40-60% GC content to promote stable primer-DNA interaction.

Risk of Contamination

Contamination is a major concern in PCR as it can lead to false-positive results. Several practices can minimize this risk:

  • Dedicated Spaces: Separate areas for sample preparation and PCR amplification.
  • Use of Barrier Tips: Tips with filters prevent sample carryover.
  • Regular Cleaning: Surfaces and equipment should be decontaminated regularly.

Equipment and Setup Requirements

Setting up a PCR laboratory requires specific equipment:

  • Thermal Cycler: For cycling through the different temperature steps of PCR.
  • Pipettes and Tips: For accurate measurement and transfer of liquids.
  • Gel Electrophoresis Equipment: For analyzing PCR products.
  • UV Transilluminator: For visualizing DNA fragments post-electrophoresis.

Comparative Advantages

When to Use Nested PCR

Nested PCR is ideal under certain conditions:

  • Low Abundance Targets: Increases the detection sensitivity.
  • Complex Samples: Helps discern the target sequence from a background of non-specific products.
  • High Specificity Required: Useful in applications like pathogen detection in clinical samples.

Benefits of Real-Time PCR in Clinical Diagnostics

Real-time PCR revolutionizes clinical diagnostics with several benefits:

  • Rapid Results: Critical for timely disease management.
  • Quantitative Data: Essential for understanding viral load in infections.
  • High Throughput: Can process multiple samples simultaneously.
ALSO READ:  Difference Between Pendant And Chandelier

Decision Factors for Method Selection

Choosing between PCR methods involves considering:

  • Purpose of the Test: Qualitative or quantitative analysis.
  • Sample Type: Quality and quantity of the starting material.
  • Budget: Real-time PCR equipment and reagents can be more expensive.

Challenges and Limitations

Limitations of Nested PCR

While powerful, nested PCR has limitations:

  • Complexity: Requires careful handling to avoid contamination.
  • Time-Consuming: Two rounds of PCR mean longer processing times.

Technical Challenges in Real-Time PCR

Real-time PCR faces its own set of challenges:

  • Fluorescence Interference: Background fluorescence can affect quantification accuracy.
  • Primer-Dimer Formation: Can give false signals if not properly managed.

Mitigating Common PCR Issues

Effective strategies to overcome PCR challenges include:

  • Optimizing Primer Concentrations: To reduce non-specific amplification.
  • Using High-Quality Reagents: To minimize the risk of contamination.
  • Robust Protocol Development: To ensure reproducibility and accuracy.

Future of PCR Technology

Innovations in PCR Methodologies

Recent advancements are pushing the boundaries of PCR capabilities:

  • Digital PCR: Provides absolute quantification of DNA without the need for calibration curves.
  • Multiplex PCR: Allows simultaneous amplification of multiple targets in a single reaction.

Emerging Trends in PCR Applications

PCR technology continues to find new applications:

  • Cancer Research: Detecting minimal residual disease and monitoring treatment response.
  • Environmental Testing: Tracking biodiversity through eDNA analysis.

Impact of Technology Advancements on PCR Accuracy and Utility

Technological improvements enhance PCR’s:

  • Sensitivity and Specificity: Making it possible to detect even a single molecule of DNA.
  • Flexibility and Scalability: Adapting to a wide range of scientific inquiries and diagnostic needs.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is conventional nested PCR?

Conventional nested PCR involves two rounds of PCR to increase the specificity and sensitivity of the amplification. It uses two pairs of primers, with the second set intended to bind within the first PCR product, reducing background and increasing the likelihood of detecting target sequences.

How does real-time PCR work?

Real-time PCR tracks the amplification of DNA during the PCR process in real time. This is achieved through fluorescent markers that emit a signal proportional to the amount of DNA generated, allowing for the quantification of DNA without additional steps.

What are the main advantages of real-time PCR over conventional PCR?

Real-time PCR offers significant advantages over conventional PCR, including faster processing times, quantification of DNA, and lower risk of contamination since the process does not require post-PCR handling. This makes it highly suitable for medical diagnostics and quantitative research.

Can conventional nested PCR detect single nucleotide variations?

Yes, conventional nested PCR can be extremely sensitive in detecting single nucleotide variations due to its high specificity, especially when optimized with precise primers and stringent conditions.


In the exploration of PCR techniques, it becomes evident that choosing between conventional nested and real-time PCR depends largely on the specific requirements of the study or diagnostic test. While conventional nested PCR excels in sensitivity and specificity, real-time PCR stands out for its speed and quantitative capabilities.

Ultimately, the advancement of PCR technologies continues to enhance genetic analysis, offering more precise, efficient, and scalable solutions. As researchers and diagnosticians lean into these innovations, the potential for scientific breakthroughs and improved patient outcomes looks ever more promising.

Leave a Comment